Enjoy the Tavern Selects Dinner Menu from Monday -Wednesday through June
Local Peeko Oysters
ON THE HALF SHELL*
Finger Lime Mignonette
Half $24/ Dozen $48
CHERRYWOOD GRILLED OYSTERS*
Pickled Strawberry Mignonette
half $24 / dozen $48
For the Table
CLAMS CASINO – $24
Smoked Bacon, Parmesan, Saltines
FRIED CALAMARI – $22
Calabrian Aioli, Marinara
JUMBO LUMP CRAB DIP – $28
Toasted Baguette, Thyme, Lemon
SAFFRON ARANCINI – $18
Sweet Corn, Chive Aioli
MEATBALLS – $24
Parmesan, Grilled Sourdough
Starters
YELLOWFIN TUNA CRUDO* – $24
Ginger Gastrique, Cucumber, Chili Oil, Mint
BIBB LETTUCE SALAD – $18
Sourdough Croutons, Shawondasee Cheese, Dijon Vinaigrette
CAESAR SALAD – $20
Crispy Parmesan, Focaccia Croutons
Add Chicken – $8 / Add Shrimp $11
GARDEN TOMATO SALAD – $22
Burrata, Pickled Melon, Aged Balsamic, Basil
RED AND GOLDEN BEET SALAD – $20
Citrus, Radish, Strawberry, Pistachio, Mint
SWEET LONG ISLAND CORN SOUP – $18
Cherrywood Grilled Corn, Chili Oil
Mains
GRILLED MONTAUK SHRIMP SPAGHETTI – $34
Grilled Shrimp, White Wine, Lemon Cream Sauce
POTATO GNOCCHI – $36
Parmesan, Morels, Asparagus, Peas, Pickled Ají Dulce, Orange-Parmesan Sauce
SICILIAN EGGPLANT PARMESAN – $32
Tomato, Basil, Garlic
BLACK BASS – $38
Cherrywood Grilled, Ramp Pesto, Charred Chicories
GRILLED DAY BOAT SCALLOPS* – $42
Parmesan-Pea Broth, Sweet Corn, Squash
GREEN CIRCLE FARMS CHICKEN – $38
Maitake Mushrooms, Spinach, Mashed Potatoes
Dry Aged Beef
TAVERN RIBEYE BURGER* – $32
Crispy Bacon, Cheddar, Brioche Bun, French Fries
NY STRIP STEAK* – $54
French Fries, Haricot Verts, Chimichurri
Stone Fired Pizzas
NAPOLITANO – $22
Fresh Mozzarella, Plum Tomatoes
SPICY SOPPRESSATA – $26
Caciocavallo Cheese, Hot Honey, Fresno Peppers, Oregano
PECONIC BAY CLAM* – $28
Pickled Chilis, Parmigiano-Reggiano
BROCCOLI RABE- $26
Caciocavallo Cheese, Garlic, Olive, Chili
Sides
FRENCH FRIES – $9
MASHED POTATOES – $10
CHARRED BROCCOLI RABE – $12
SAUTEED GREENS – $12
MAC AND CHEESE – $12
Effective Wednesday, May 7 2025
*Consuming raw or undercooked meats, poultry, seafood, shellfish or eggs may increase your risk of foodbourne illness.
Before placing your order, please inform your server if a person in your party has a food allergy
